Emmaus Baptist Church was founded in 1874 and was originally located in a brush arbor on Rickert Street. In 1883, the church changed its name to First Baptist and moved to the corner of Green and Garfield Streets (right). The first pastor of the congregation was Rev. Charlie Brown, who is buried in the Green Street Cemetery, along with his wife. Other pastors have included Revs. A.H. Lewis, O.J. Allen, and J.W. Croom. In 1967, the congregation voted to purchase property and build a new church on the corner of Garfield and Old Salisbury Road, which is where it operates today (below left).
Rev. Caesar Allison (below right) was a Baptist minister who was a charter member of the church. He and his son, Caesar Allison Jr., are both buried at Green Street.